Last updated 2/20/2024
| Round 1 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Corbin Carroll |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Matt Olson |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Marcus Semien |
| 4 | Texas | Bo Bichette |
| 5 | San Francisco | Freddie Freeman |
| 6 | Oakland | Aaron Judge |
| 7 | La Grange | Luis Arraez |
| 8 | Windy City | Gerrit Cole |
| 9 | Hellgate | Cody Bellinger |
| 10 | Prescott | Pete Alonso |
| 11 | Springfield | Vladimir Guerrero |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Michael Harris |
| Round 2 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | George Kirby |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Kyle Bradish |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Gabriel Moreno |
| 4 | Texas | Framber Valdez |
| 5 | San Francisco | J.T. Realmuto |
| 6 | Oakland | Jake Burger |
| 7 | La Grange | Manny Machado |
| 8 | Windy City | Tyler Glasnow |
| 9 | Hellgate | Randy Arozarena |
| 10 | Prescott | Keibert Ruiz |
| 11 | Springfield | Bryan Reynolds |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Gleyber Torres |
| Round 3 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Andres Gimenez |
| 2 | Shenandoah | David Bednar |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Jordan Montgomery |
| 4 | Texas | Bryan De La Cruz |
| 5 | San Francisco | Zach Eflin |
| 6 | Oakland | Zack Wheeler |
| 7 | La Grange | Austin Hays |
| 8 | Windy City | Brandon Woodruff |
| 9 | Hellgate | Merrill Kelly |
| 10 | Prescott | Joe Musgrove |
| 11 | Springfield | Nate Eovaldi |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Michael King |
| Round 4 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Camilo Doval |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Clay Holmes |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Oneil Cruz |
| 4 | Texas | CJ Abrams |
| 5 | San Francisco | Ke’Bryan Hayes |
| 6 | Oakland | Freddy Peralta |
| 7 | La Grange | Jose Berrios |
| 8 | Windy City | Max Muncy |
| 9 | Hellgate | Wade Miley |
| 10 | Prescott | Joel Payamps |
| 11 | Springfield | Salvador Perez |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Matt Brash |
| Round 5 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Jose Alvarado |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Anthony Santander |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Shea Langeliers |
| 4 | Texas | Ha-Seong Kim |
| 5 | San Francisco | Nicholas Castellanos |
| 6 | Oakland | Marcus Stroman |
| 7 | La Grange | Brayan Bello |
| 8 | Windy City | Alex Verdugo |
| 9 | Hellgate | Alejandro Kirk |
| 10 | Prescott | Seiya Suzuki |
| 11 | Springfield | Reid Detmers |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Carlos Correa |
| Round 6 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Ryan Pepiot |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Ryan Pressly |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Steven Kwan |
| 4 | Texas | Eugenio Suarez |
| 5 | San Francisco | George Springer |
| 6 | Oakland | Seth Lugo |
| 7 | La Grange | Wander Franco |
| 8 | Windy City | Justin Turner |
| 9 | Hellgate | Jason Foley |
| 10 | Prescott | Ryan McMahon |
| 11 | Springfield | Yusei Kikuchi |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Dylan Cease |